FieldGuidetoQuilts.com
Classic Shoofly ***

Shoofly (or Shoo Fly, or Shoo-fly) is one of the oldest, best-known quilt blocks. Traditionally, it's a nine-patch, laid out on a 3x3 grid. There are many variations and many names. We've also included a few four-patch Churn Dashes -- there aren't all that many.
Five-patch Shoofly blocks overlap with five-patch Churn Dash blocks. Click here:

Shoo Fly
Joseph's Coat
Prairie Queen
A Dandy
Grecian Designs
Double Monkey Wrench
Classic
Churn
Dash
Churn Dash (LAC)
Puss in the Corner
Triangles & Stripes
Fence Row
Quilt
Fence Row


Shoo Fly

Shoo Fly
American Farmer
1896
The 8-cornered Box/Simplicity

The two-color, nine-patch design at left is the classic Shoo Fly block. It was first published as The Eight-Cornered Box in 1896 by The American Farmer, but that drab name is long forgotten.

Shoo Fly, also spelled Shoofly and Shoo-Fly, was #276 in the Ladies Art Company's 1897 catalog. At least eight other blocks go by the same name, however. You can see the strength and simplicity of the design in the mockup at right. The design holds its own if it's made entirely of scraps, as long as they're divided into lights and darks.

No one knows how old the block is. Decades before the LAC catalog came out, a "fly fan" or "shoo fly fan" was a table-top wind-up fan that was supposed to scare away insects. The blades spun horizontally, like a ceiling fan's. The one at right is a cast-iron model with foldaway wings.






Shoofly

At right, a Shoo-Fly Fan
for the dining table. These windup fans became popular during the 19th century. The blades were horizontal to the table when they were set at the top of the center rod.

Photo courtesy of liveauctioneers.com
item 10512723


Joseph's Coat


Joseph's Coat

Joseph's Coat
Finley
1929

Joseph's Coat
Finley
1929
Joseph's Coat in four colors
It's easier to see Joseph's Coat's resemblance to a Shoo Fly in four (or more) colors than in the three-color version that Ruth Finley included in her 1929 book. In the block at left, dark magenta shows the shoofly shape.

In Finley's day, quilters knew that the block was supposed to be a rainbow of colors. The block name refers to the Old Testament account of Joseph. Joseph was his father Israel's favorite child, the son of Israel's wife Rachael.

Eventually, his jealous half-brothers sold Joseph into slavery and brought back his bloodied "coat of many colors" to persuade their father that Joseph had been killed.


Joseph ended up in Egypt, became a government honcho, and married the Pharoah's daughter. Years later, when the brothers came to Egypt during a famine, Joseph, to make a long story short, forgave them. The whole family of Israel moved to Egypt. That was where their descendants stayed until Moses led their escape.

Although quilters consider the block a 9-patch, the block is laid out on a 18- by 18-square grid, according to Beyer's Quilter's Album of Patchwork Patterns.

A Dandy

A Dandy
Stone
1906
Clara Stone's 1906 Practical Needlework included this unusual Shoo Fly variation. We've reversed the light and dark colors to show where the seamlines may have been. That's our best guess; our copy of this publication is too dark to show them.
A Dandy

Prairie Queen



Prairie Queen in two colors
Prairie Queen
Finley
1929

Prairie Queen in alternative colors
Ruth Finley included this two-color block in her 1929 book Old Patchwork Quilts. The resemblance to a Shoofly is muted because the center block is in the background color.

The block is puzzling because the four 2x2 checkerboards are arranged so that one checkerboard (the bottom one in our graphic) is reversed.

As a result, multiple blocks form a lattice made up of horizontal bars with a checkerboard look and vertical bars with alternating rectangles. We've shown both styles in the whole-quilt mockups at right.


Churn Dash

Double Monkey Wrench/Old Mill Design/Hens and Chickens/Double T/Shoo Fly/Sherman's March/Monkey Wrench/Love Knot/Hole-in-the-Barn-Door/Puss-in-the-Corner/Shoo-Fly/Lincoln's Platform/Indian Hammer/Quail's Nest/Broken Plate/Joan's Doll Quilt/Fisherman's Reel/Picture Frame/Ludlow's Favorite

Grecian Designs
Ladies Art Co., #152
1897










Double Monkey Wrench
Finley 1929
Churn Dash
Colors showing the basic Shoofly pattern

The sheer number of names for this venerable block say more about its age than anything we could. Churn Dash is the most popular. They are all made from one pattern laid out on a 6x6 grid. Some quilters will still call it a nine-patch. As long as you don't call it a four- or five-patch, you're golden.

The oldest published block in this group is Grecian Designs, from the 1897 Ladies Art Company catalog. It's the only one of these blocks that isn't usually called Churn Dash for short.

Double Monkey Wrench, from Ruth Finley's 1929 Old Patchwork Quilts, is the second oldest published name.

The third block is an example made by About.com's quilting editor, Janet Wickell. Her instructions are linked from the "Make It!" icon above.

The alternative names above are from Brackman's Encyclopedia of Pieced Quilt Patterns.

Below, an antique Double Monkey Wrench quilt.
Photo courtesy of eBay seller French72.


Churn Dash
Grecian Designs
Double Monkey Wrench

Puss in the Corner


Puss in the Corner
Ickes, 1949
The name is from The Standard Book of Quilt Making and Collecting by Marguerite Ickis (1949). The design is a four-patch (laid out on 4x4 grid).

Puss in the Corner

Churn Dash

Churn Dash
Ladies Art Co. #112
1897

Picture Frame/The Picture Frame/Hole in the Barn Door/Sherman's March

The LAC's block #112 is a churn dash variation with rare slim proportions. It is drawn up on an 8x8 grid.

The "picture frame" names came from Clara Stone (#127) and the Kansas City Star (1955). Yvonne Khin also found it called Hole-in-the-Barn-Door and Sherman's March(Collector's Dictionary of Quilt Names and Patterns).





Churn Dash

Triangles & Stripes

Triangles & Stripes
Ladies Art Co. #229
1897
Magic Box/Squares & Stripes

The Ladies Art Company published this pretty variation on the Churn Dash as its #229 in 1897. The LAC offered the pattern at 13 inches and 15 cents. Or you could buy the diagram for 5 cents.

You don't even have to pay that much
: You can get yours free by clicking on the "Make It!" icon.
Triangles & Stripes

Fence Row Quilt

Fence Row Quilt
Kansas City Star
1931
Fence Row Quilt
Hall
1935
In 1931, Eveline Foland of the Kansas City Star published a whole-quilt pattern called Fence Row. Its Shoo Fly blocks are placed on the diagonal, creating a zigzag row between the blocks for fancy stitching.

Four years later, Carrie Hall published a similar block as an elongated hexagon. You make Hall's block into a full quilt by adding a half-square triangle to each end (light pink here) and setting the rows side by side).

In the Star's design, the Shoo Flys are offset about a half block. Hall's design is a checkerboard of pieced and plain blocks. It varies the look of the quilt, especially with the plain blocks in a third color.




Fence Row (KCS) as a whole quilt
Above, Hall's block with half-squares added at each end. Side by side Shoofly and plain blocks make a checkerboard. The Star's blocks, offset,
create a zigzag.